1. Education
Send to a Friend via Email
Kallie Szczepanski

Was Marco Polo a Fraud?

By April 17, 2012

Follow me on:

The young Marco Polo, who left Venice at 17 and returned at almost 40 from his Asian travels.

For centuries, people have expressed doubt about the stories in Marco Polo's travel account. Did he really see all of those wondrous things? Did he even go to China, and live at Kublai Khan's court?

Initially, Polo's fellow Europeans doubted his tales of unbelievable Chinese innovations like black rocks that burned (coal) or paper money that could be exchanged for gold or any kind of product. To be fair, paper currency is a strange idea - but much more convenient than carrying around huge slabs of gold or salt to pay for things!

More recent skeptics have focused on what they perceive as gaps in Marco Polo's otherwise keen observations of China. For example, he never mentions women with bound feet. However, the Venetian spent the vast majority of his time in the Mongol court, where women would not have had Han Chinese-style "lotus feet."

Another example is the Great Wall of China, which also receives no notice at all in Marco Polo's story. However, the Wall was in considerable disrepair at this point in history, and the Mongols had no interest in reinforcing it - after all, it was built to keep people like them out of China! Kublai Khan would have been terribly inconvenienced by a continuous wall dividing his Mongolian and Chinese territories. In fact, it wasn't until the ethnic-Han Ming Dynasty defeated the Mongol Yuan rulers that the current unified Great Wall went up... to keep the Mongols out.

In the end, there's no way to definitively prove whether or not Marco Polo went to China. For my part, though, I believe that he did.

Drawing of a young Marco Polo from Stock Montage / Getty Images.

Comments

July 17, 2013 at 9:40 pm
(1) La Verne says:

It’s an interesting question… As what I have known, the book entitle Marco Polo’s Travel was not really personally written by Marco Polo. Though Marco Polo himself have written his own diary or observation but he gave that to a romantic writer before he was imprisoned. So, partly, the books was not that 100% accurate… there might additions from the writer just to make a more interesting story.

Leave a Comment


Line and paragraph breaks are automatic. Some HTML allowed: <a href="" title="">, <b>, <i>, <strike>
  1. About.com
  2. Education
  3. Asian History

©2014 About.com. All rights reserved.